Which stock is better, AG or PAAS?

Comparing Silver Stocks: AG Versus PAAS

When evaluating whether First Majestic Silver (AG) or Pan American Silver (PAAS) makes a better investment, performance heavily depends on your preferred timeline. Short-term momentum and long-term stability tell two completely different stories.

Looking at short-term returns, AG has recently outpaced its competitor. In the year-to-date period, AG posts a positive return of 4.02%, whereas PAAS lags behind with a decline of -12.07%.

However, the narrative shifts when analyzing a multi-year horizon. Over the past decade, PAAS has proven to be the more resilient long-term holding, generating a solid annualized return of 11.09%. In contrast, AG yields a much lower annualized return of just 1.20% across the same ten-year span.

Ultimately, investors must weigh AG's recent growth spurts against PAAS's proven track record of enduring long-term value.